How the "sinner's prayer" does not fit my theology

I read this blog post by Ben Irwin today.  click to read here 
I share it with you and encourage your thoughts and reflections in the "comments" section.
Here are some of my reflections:

While I was not raised with the "sinner's prayer," I have been influenced by people who did pray this prayer. I may not have even been 20 when I attended a tent meeting with a friend when an altar call was made. My friend told me they would go up with me so I could be "saved." I responded by saying I was baptized as a baby and I was saved. I did not need this altar call to change that.
It is a deep, pivotal memory for me.
I would much rather tell people they are beloved Children of the Holy One than tell them to first think of themselves as sinners. We make mistakes. We struggle with ethical decisions. We live in a world where we are bombarded with images of indecency, with impropriety, with lies, violence, and indiscretions. We can blame or point fingers, shame or ignore. But when we see that each is a child of the Holy One, when we raise our young to understand that they are beloved, then we can have more hope for the world. There is no rule that we have to like the behavior, or that we shouldn't try to change the behavior. But we are each first born in the image of God. We are not born sinners. We are born beloved.


Small Potatoes

We did it again.  Even though we promised we wouldn’t, we did.

Awakened from a post-marathon, post- church, Vikings game nap by an urgent ringing of the doorbell, I jumped to my feet and answered it, still catching up to my heartbeat and hoping that the cramp in my foot would not cause me to stumble, I opened the door to a dirty man who barely said hello before launching into his sales-pitch.  “I’m from ___ and we just did your neighbor’s ___.  Would you like yours done?”

At this point I deferred to my husband, still dazed and unable to know whether or not this was a good idea.  Amazingly able to move after running 26.2 miles, he went out the door with the man to discuss the project and the cost.  After agreeing (we said we wouldn’t do this anymore!) with a price, the men set to work.

Their equipment, their vehicle, their bodies were broken, dirty and seemed to lack in general maintenance.  Requiring a jump for their vehicle, they struggled to get engines working.  After a while there was another ring of the bell and the question, “Can the little boy use your bathroom?”  Of course he could.  But, I thought, “There’s a little boy out there?”  These two men were also responsible for this four year old boy, who desperately wanted to be in the house with us.  So we let him.
 
The boy told me about his action figure, discussed the movie (Big Hero 6) it came from, told me of his favorite super heroes and knew Marvel and Disney.  He talked; he played with some toys and was generally a lovely child who lived a different life than we do.

Outside, equipment broke down and the men struggled to finish the job.  At one point they told my husband it may take more material than originally quoted and we thought they would talk to us about that, considering they would change the cost appropriately. 

When they came to be paid, they called to the boy, told my husband that they used three times the material and would now charge us three times the cost.  They wanted cash.  Of course. 

All of those negotiations happened without my knowledge.  A drive to the ATM, and the men were paid.  The work may or may not be complete.  An agreement that they would come back today to “touch up” was struck.

When my husband told me how the story ended, he had that look on his face that he gets when he has been duped or lied to and he cannot find a good way out of the situation.  He was angry that he was lied to and that, yet again, he fell for what may or may not be considered a swindle.  And he repeated his mantra, “Never again.”

But then he said something that was more important than the situation.  He said, “These people have so much less than we do.  It’s only money.  They need it more right now, and we had some we could give.”

Wow.  I had to agree.  Their truck was in terrible shape.  Their generator wasn’t working well.  They were out, on a Sunday afternoon, trying to make some money for what?  To feed the boy?  To feed a house-full or two of hungry people?  To buy a clean shirt? 

Sure, we don’t like being lied to, but these men worked for their pay, albeit double (they compromised) what was quoted.  They didn’t explain their need, or bemoan their situation.  They knocked on our door and asked for work, and it was a project we needed completed.

It made me think about the sermon I heard that morning.  The church I attended kicked off their annual stewardship drive with a theme of JOY.  (Abundant…Joy…Overflowing...Generosity…from 2 Cor. 8:1-7).  The priest spoke about giving.  She opened with a personal story of receiving four Twins tickets when she needed only two and then finding two people in the crowd to give the extra tickets to.  The couple who received the tickets, she learned, has a child in Mayo with cancer.  The child loves baseball and though he could not come to the game, his parents were bringing nearly every souvenir they could afford back to the hospital for their son.

She talked about the recent study that identified that individuals who give receive more than the person who receives.  She called that the “joy of giving.”  We were asked to think of a time when we bought a gift for someone that made us so excited that we could barely contain ourselves.  She called that the “intimacy of giving.”  She said that when we give, we “draw closer to one another in the spirit of giving.”

During the education hour, the finance person gave an illustration of what tithing means.  To tithe means you give 10% of your income.  He had ten potatoes on a table.  He removed one potato from the line and said this one potato isn’t all that much.  There are still nine potatoes to supply our needs.  He challenged those in attendance to increase their previous year’s pledge by 10%.  Over the course of time, a family could conceivably give 10% of their income.  He did not say that all 10% needed to go to the church, and I believe that giving 10% can be divided up amongst many places and faces in need.  But the image of the potatoes, the humble, abundant potato, made sense to me.

          Yesterday we gave a couple of men and a small boy a small handful of French fries.

Here is the prayer that was given as a book mark to everyone in attendance at the education hour yesterday.

     Disturb us, Lord, when we are too pleased with ourselves, when our dreams have come true because we dream too little, when we have arrived safely because we sailed too close to the shore.
     Disturb us, Lord, when with the abundance of the things we possess we have lost our thirst for the water of life.
     Stir us, Lord to dare more boldly, to venture on the wider seas where storms will show your mastery, where in losing sight of the land we shall find the stars.       
     We ask you to push back the horizons of our hope, and to push us into the future in strength, courage, love and hope.  
     Amen.